1 star = Will not use again, 2: Not so hot, 3: OK, 4: Pretty good, 5: Great! Note: You must be logged in to submit a rating.
Rating: 2.6/5 (11 votes cast)
Vote Total Breakdown by Player Level
Will not use again
Not so hot
OK
Pretty good
Great!
TOTALS
3
3
2
1
2
Uncategorized
3
3
2
1
2
VN:R_U [1.7.2_963]
Please Rate Reed Properties
Please rate specific attributes of this reedmaker, on average, compared to others. In this section, more stars are not necessarily better; some of these are matters of taste. Ratings in this section are not linked to overall rating, above. You must rate all the categories in order to submit a vote ; average scores so far are displayed.
RESISTANCE (1 star = easy blowing, 5 = resistant)
TIMBRE (1 star = covered/dark, 5 = brilliant/bright)
MAX DYNAMIC (1 star = pp, 5 = ff)
PITCH LEVEL (1 star = flat, 5 = sharp)
STABILITY (1 star = stable/rigid, 5 = flexible/wild)
CRACKS, LEAKS, DEFECTS (1 star = rare, 5 = common)
Professional--Plays Most days--Used More than 10 reedmakers--Reedmaking: Professional reedmaker
I used his profiled cane when I was first learning to make reeds. It was such a nice learning tool to have a reed that can make a crow just after tying it and clipping the tip. The profiler that is used leaves a very nice tip and heart. I would suggest his cane to any young students just starting the reed making process and need less frustration than is usually. And after just looking at his price list, if you are a busy teacher that can’t spend time making 10 reeds a week for students that are just going to shred the tip, $12 is a deal for his finished reeds.
As a student studying in a conservatory, I think Bill’s reed is not awful, not mess at all. I do not agree with someone saying Bill’s reed is so bad that can’t be even worse.
I bought Bill’s reed very long time ago, and I still remember what the texture, what’s the sound was when I’m playing with. Actually, it sounds great.
But I think he can improve with the windows. I think if the window part can be scrape it more distinct, the sound would project more clear, because sometimes the reed sounds a bit too dark.
This is Bill Roscoe again. On every reed I sell there is a note on the bottom of the box that says, “Guaranteed to play.” Anyone who is not happy with my reeds can give me a call. My number is listed. I will either replace the reed or give the customer their money back. Bill Roscoe
As a professional woodwind player I used Bill’s reeds over a two year period. As time went on I did a little customizing and like all commercially available reeds you play on the best of a bunch. I have 10 reeds in my reed case now and fuss with them during practice….come show time I go with my best reed. My advice is to buy lots and pick the best. If you go with a reed that costs 25 dollars you don’t have that luxury . Bill is great to do business with….professional and friendly.
I am Bill Roscoe who makes ‘Bill Roscoe Oboe Reeds”. There are some other interesting comments on my web page located at: http://www.doublereeds.com
Once there click on “Comments” to see what professionsl oboist and teachers say about my reeds.
I will finish 50 years as a reed maker next year in 1959.
cokomo January 31, 2012: Lyn Davies I don’t know if the reed stock is different or what, but I have just purchased three reeds from Rush’s and the next day two of them were cracked.
geekygeek January 28, 2012: Jones Double Reed Products Good for beginners, and the medium soft is quite easily to blow on. Pretty durable and consistent. They’re good beginner reeds but the sound quality isn’t so fantastic. I use just a regular knife (even though you should buy a...
Anonymous January 14, 2012: SUGGESTION BOX Thank you so much for this site. I have a limited # of manufacturers where I lived, and they all sound bad( Jones, Emerald, Richards). Anyway, you could improve the collected ratings page by sepeating them by area(USA, Asia, Australia, Canada,...
Anonymous January 14, 2012: The Reedmaker For me, these reeds are the best. I ordered three reeds from him and two of them were too hard, so I sent them back, and he scraped more and threw another one in! Every one of them were the best sounding reeds I have played so far, not that I have...
Peter VandeBurgt January 14, 2012: SUGGESTION BOX The link to my eBay site has changed; here’s the new link. Thanks for good work! http://www.ebay.ca/itm/2807606 26694?ssPageName=STRK:MESELX:I T&_trksid=p3984.m1586.l264 9
Klezmer January 4, 2012: Reed Expression Normall have made my own for years, but do not have the time. I purchased 5 medium-soft German scrape reeds. I just adjusted them to my own chops and all five play very well. They respond easy and have very good intonation. I am trying a couple EH...
11 comments
I used his profiled cane when I was first learning to make reeds. It was such a nice learning tool to have a reed that can make a crow just after tying it and clipping the tip. The profiler that is used leaves a very nice tip and heart. I would suggest his cane to any young students just starting the reed making process and need less frustration than is usually. And after just looking at his price list, if you are a busy teacher that can’t spend time making 10 reeds a week for students that are just going to shred the tip, $12 is a deal for his finished reeds.
Sound is terrible.
I have used Bill’s reeds for a couple of years.They were great! I truly love ‘em.Besides.the price is very reasonable.
I have used Bill’s reeds for a couple years.I thought they were great ! I truly love ‘em.Besides,they are at a very reasonable price.
As a student studying in a conservatory, I think Bill’s reed is not awful, not mess at all. I do not agree with someone saying Bill’s reed is so bad that can’t be even worse.
I bought Bill’s reed very long time ago, and I still remember what the texture, what’s the sound was when I’m playing with. Actually, it sounds great.
But I think he can improve with the windows. I think if the window part can be scrape it more distinct, the sound would project more clear, because sometimes the reed sounds a bit too dark.
Best wishes to you Bill,
Justin
This is Bill Roscoe again. On every reed I sell there is a note on the bottom of the box that says, “Guaranteed to play.” Anyone who is not happy with my reeds can give me a call. My number is listed. I will either replace the reed or give the customer their money back. Bill Roscoe
As a professional woodwind player I used Bill’s reeds over a two year period. As time went on I did a little customizing and like all commercially available reeds you play on the best of a bunch. I have 10 reeds in my reed case now and fuss with them during practice….come show time I go with my best reed. My advice is to buy lots and pick the best. If you go with a reed that costs 25 dollars you don’t have that luxury . Bill is great to do business with….professional and friendly.
Truly hate them. Nothing good to say. No loud sound I am looking for.
I am Bill Roscoe who makes ‘Bill Roscoe Oboe Reeds”. There are some other interesting comments on my web page located at:
http://www.doublereeds.com
Once there click on “Comments” to see what professionsl oboist and teachers say about my reeds.
I will finish 50 years as a reed maker next year in 1959.
They’re a mess.
Gross.
Gross.
Gross.
Awful. They look machine made and sound tinny.